Skip to content
MountainsideFoam & Coating, Sacramento24/7 roof line(916) 963-8097

Replace cedar shake safely

Wood shake roof replacement in Sacramento, CA

Cedar shake looks good for a while, then it splits, cups and burns, and the insurance company starts asking questions you cannot answer.

Typical range$9.45 to $19.80
Pricedper sq ft
Phone lineOpen 24/7
Crew tearing off weathered cedar shake from a ranch home roof in Carmichael with plywood sheathing being laid over spaced boa
Quick answer

Wood shake replacement means tearing off the old cedar, repairing the deck and installing a fire-rated roof such as Class A shingle, stone-coated steel or lightweight tile. Most homes take 3 to 7 working days. Typical cost is 9.45 to 19.80 per sq ft depending on the new material, deck repairs and roof shape.

What this job involves

Many 1960s to 1980s homes in Carmichael, Fair Oaks, Granite Bay, Orangevale and the foothills were built with cedar shake, or had shake covered over with a second roof later. Shake that was never pressure-treated lets embers land and burn. After decades of Sacramento sun and winter rain it also splits, cups, grows moss under trees and loses nails to rot.

Replacing it is more than swapping materials. The old shake and any overlay must come off, the deck has to be checked, and the new roof must be chosen with fire, weight and cost in mind. Mountainside tears off the old roof, repairs the sheathing, hauls everything away and installs the new system you pick.

Warning signs

Signs your shake roof is done

1Split, cupped or curled shakes

Shakes that curl up at the edges or crack along the grain let wind-driven rain behind them. Once many are affected, patching only delays the problem.

2Moss and dark staining

Heavy moss under oak or pine holds moisture against the wood and speeds rot. Scraping it off often loosens more shakes than it saves.

3Daylight in the attic

Thin lines of light through the deck mean gaps in the roof. Spaced sheathing under shake naturally shows this, but wet stains next to the light signal real leaks.

4Insurer questions or nonrenewal

A letter from your insurer about untreated wood roofing is a strong sign to start planning. Wildfire concerns are the main reason these roofs get flagged.

5Missing or slipped shakes

Rusted nails and rotted ends let shakes slide out. Bare spots expose the paper underneath, which was never meant to be the final weather barrier.

6Previous overlay on top

A shingle layer installed over shake hides rot underneath and adds weight. Water that gets through the top layer sits in the wood and cannot dry.

Why tear-off is required

Putting a new roof over shake is a bad idea for several reasons. The uneven surface telegraphs through shingles, the nailing is unreliable, and the old wood keeps the fire hazard in place. Most shingle makers and building departments also expect tear-off over wood shake, and a Class A fire rating depends on the correct assembly, not just the top layer. Shake roofs are usually installed over spaced sheathing, also called skip decking, which is boards with gaps between them. A modern roof needs a solid surface. We cover the skips with plywood or OSB sheathing, replace any rotted boards and then add underlayment. That step adds cost but gives the new roof a flat, nailable deck.

An ember-resistant mesh vent fitted into a roof ridge with Class A shingle caps
An ember-resistant mesh vent fitted into a roof ridge with Class A shingle caps.

Replacement options and weight

A Class A asphalt shingle is the lowest-cost option and the lightest. Stone-coated steel gives a shake or tile look with a fire-rated assembly and low weight, usually lasting longer. Concrete tile is heavy, so a structural check may be needed first. Metal and composite shake-look products are also available. Each has a different price, life span and warranty, and we lay out the trade-offs on your roof before you pick. Insurers vary in how they treat each material, so ask yours what they prefer before choosing. Color and profile matter on streets with HOA design rules, and we can bring samples if needed.

  • Class A architectural asphalt shingle
  • Stone-coated steel shake profile
  • Concrete tile after a weight check
  • Standing seam or metal shake panels

Fire zones and ember-resistant details

Parts of Placer, El Dorado and Nevada counties fall in fire hazard severity zones, and California's building rules for wildfire-prone areas can apply to reroofs there. The rules vary by address, so we check with the local building department. Where they apply, requirements may cover roof assembly rating, ember-resistant vents and sealed or screened eaves. Even outside a mapped zone, small details help. Closed eaves, metal drip edge, noncombustible gutters and ember-resistant vents reduce the places an ember can lodge. We often recommend these upgrades during a shake replacement since the roof edges are already open.

How the job runs

Our process for wood shake roof replacement

Six steps, in the order the crew does them on a Sacramento roof.

  1. Step 1Inspect deck and attic

    We check the shake layers, deck type, attic framing and ventilation to find rot, overlays and any structural limits on new materials.

  2. Step 2Choose the new roof

    We compare Class A shingle, stone-coated steel and tile on cost, weight, fire rating and life span, and price each for your roof.

  3. Step 3Protect and tear off

    Landscaping and walls are covered, then crews strip every layer of shake and overlay down to the sheathing in sections.

  4. Step 4Sheath and repair deck

    Skip decking is covered with plywood or OSB, rotted boards are replaced, and drip edge and valley metal go in.

  5. Step 5Install new roofing

    Underlayment, flashings and the chosen roofing go on in order, with ember-resistant vents where they apply or you choose them.

  6. Step 6Clean up and walkthrough

    Debris is hauled off, magnet sweeps pick up nails, and we walk the finished roof with you before we leave.

Cost

What wood shake roof replacement costs in Sacramento

MS-220 Wood Shake Roof Replacement2026 range
$9.45 to $19.80per sq ft

A 2,400 sq ft single-story roof with shake tear-off, new OSB over skips and Class A shingles often runs around 26,800 to 33,500.

What moves the price
  • New roofing material
  • Layers to tear off
  • Sheathing and rot repair
  • Roof pitch and complexity

Compare this job with others in the Sacramento roofing cost guide.

Sacramento conditions that matter

Shake roofs cluster in Carmichael, Fair Oaks, Orangevale, Granite Bay and foothill towns where tree cover and dry summer grass raise fire concerns. Sacramento valley heat bakes the wood and winter rain keeps it wet, so shakes split and rot faster under oak shade. Embers from foothill fires can travel a long way in summer winds, which is why insurers pay attention to roof class. Building rules differ between city, county and fire district, so permits and ember-resistant vent requirements are checked address by address. Winter tear-off needs dry weather windows, so many owners book in spring or fall.

FAQ

Questions about wood shake roof replacement

Do I have to tear off cedar shake before reroofing?

Generally no. Roofing over shake leaves the fire hazard in place, hides rot and creates an uneven surface that wears the new shingles. Many manufacturers and building departments expect tear-off. If a previous owner already overlaid shake, expect both layers to come off and the deck to be checked and repaired.

Why does a shake roof need new sheathing?

Shake is nailed to spaced boards with gaps between them. Shingles, steel and tile need a solid surface. We cover the skips with plywood or OSB and replace damaged boards. This adds material and labor cost but gives a flat deck that supports modern underlayment and passes inspection.

What is the best replacement for wood shake in the foothills?

For fire resistance, Class A shingle and stone-coated steel are common picks, and tile is another if the framing can carry it. Steel lasts longest and keeps a shake look. Shingles cost least. Ask your insurer and local fire district which assemblies they prefer before you decide.

How many days will my cedar shake tear-off and new roof take?

Most single-family roofs take three to seven working days, depending on size, layers and rot. Tear-off and sheathing take the longest on shake roofs. Rain delays are common in winter, and a roof is not left open overnight. Complex rooflines or full stone-coated steel installs may run longer.

Will replacing wood shake lower my insurance cost?

It may, but nothing is promised. Some insurers consider untreated wood roofing a higher risk or decline to renew, and a Class A roof can remove that objection. Premiums depend on location, fire protection and the company. Keep the invoice and product data sheet to show your agent after the work.

Roof leaking, peeling or baking in the sun?

Call the 24/7 line. Tell us the roof type, where the water shows up or what the coating looks like, and we will tell you what we would check first and when a crew can be there.

Call (916) 963-8097
Call 24/7 (916) 963-8097